Pièce 48 - Letter from George Airy

Open original Document numérique

Zone d'identification

Cote

Add. MS a/200/48

Titre

Letter from George Airy

Date(s)

  • 14 Feb. 1843 (Production)

Niveau de description

Pièce

Étendue matérielle et support

8 pp.

Zone du contexte

Histoire archivistique

Source immédiate d'acquisition ou de transfert

Zone du contenu et de la structure

Portée et contenu

Royal Observatory Greenwich - He fully understands why Whewell should be so much attached to his own theory on tides. He strongly disagrees with Whewell 'that a fluid always tends to the condition of equilibrium and that this can be made in any way the base of a theory of motion. You would by this treat the theory of common waves (for instance) as that of water having a horizontal surface, and thus annihilate the waves altogether. Indeed I am rather surprised at this doctrine in general. When you come to particular cases, the inconsistency is remarkable. Perhaps the most curious of all the results of Laplace's theory (I mean of course with the unnatural assumption of uniform depth and no dry land) is that of the non-existence of diurnal tides; and this stands irreconcilable with your equilibrium deduction... The cases to which it will apply may be so exceedingly restricted as to be practically useless; (e.g. Laplace's uniform depth, or my canals); nevertheless the theory is so far right: the equilibrium theory could not be right under any restriction...When you say that Laplace's theory gives us no light which the equil. theory had not given before, it seems to me that there is a moral perversion; you think that success founded on false principles is at least as good as failure founded on true principles which are imperfect (in extent, not in truth). I must protest against such a judgement in toto'. He boils down Whewell's promotion of the equilibrium theory to the adverse effects Whewell thinks Laplace's theory would have on Cambridge students: 'I am free to say that the tone of my writings has been given by my vexation at seeing that you in every mathematical case and Lubbock in every case refer solely to the equilibrium theory'. He does not knock cotidal lines - 'they are the greatest advance yet made in systematically representing the observations of ocean tides, but I think them inapplicable in some cases: and especially when the well marked series of waves interfere'. He 'should be glad to lead on some attention to the theory of canal-waves with the conditions applicable to real rivers. First, I do not think that cotidal lines or mean levels can be made accurate till this is done, secondly, theory and observation can be compared to a very great extent here'. They (George and Richarda Airy) went to see a cliff blown down at Dover organised by the engineer, Cubitt. The Herschels also went [see The Illustrated London News, 4 February 1843].

Évaluation, élimination et calendrier de conservation

Accroissements

Mode de classement

Zone des conditions d'accès et d'utilisation

Conditions d'accès

Conditions de reproduction

Langue des documents

    Écriture des documents

      Notes de langue et graphie

      Caractéristiques matérielle et contraintes techniques

      Instruments de recherche

      Zone des sources complémentaires

      Existence et lieu de conservation des originaux

      Existence et lieu de conservation des copies

      Unités de description associées

      Descriptions associées

      Zone des notes

      Identifiant(s) alternatif(s)

      Mots-clés

      Mots-clés - Sujets

      Mots-clés - Lieux

      Mots-clés - Genre

      Identifiant de la description

      Identifiant du service d'archives

      Règles et/ou conventions utilisées

      Statut

      Niveau de détail

      Dates de production, de révision, de suppression

      Langue(s)

        Écriture(s)

          Sources

          Document numérique (URI externe) zone des droits

          Document numérique (Référence) zone des droits

          Document numérique (Vignette) zone des droits

          Zone des entrées