He notes that the Ali brothers have been sentenced to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and queries whether such sentences are appropriate for political misdemeanants, since such prisoners need more rigorous separation from the outside world than ordinary… read more
Refers to Gandhi’s speech at Trichinopoly and his article in Young India, in which he stated that, as non-co-operation is legally sedition under the Penal Code, he objected to the suggestion in Sir George Lloyd’s communiqué that tampering with the… read more
The opinion of O. M., in his report on the Congress, does not seem to tally with that of his subordinates, on which it is apparently based. Asks for Chelmsford’s own views on the effects of the Congress and the amnesty. Is not disappointed that extreme… read more
Refers to Montagu's telegram of 6 June regarding the Prince of Wales's visit. The non-co-operation agitation is now less active. The recantation of the Ali brothers has, he thinks, had a damping effect on the Khilafat supporters and the Gandhi movement,… read more
Expresses concern at the international publicity given to speeches made from the dock in the Ali brothers’ trial, and wonders, in the light of a possible prosecution of Gandhi, whether anything could be done to prevent such trials becoming centres of… read more
Gandhi has stated in Young India that his visit to the Viceroy and his advice to the Ali brothers to apologise was a political blunder.
(Typed.)
Has told Malaviya that, by refusing to suspend controversy during the Prince of Wales’s visit, Gandhi had given the impression that India was disloyal; and he repudiated the rumour that if the Prince was well received the Government would claim that… read more
Asks for more details of the cases mentioned in A3/10/8, and denies that threats of violence have not been dealt with because of a policy of non-interference. Is disturbed that press reports of isolated instances have been taken by the Cabinet to… read more
Simla.—Section 2. Violence has been reported in connection with the Buckingham Mills strike. The Governor has visited the area and held discussions with a deputation. (Bombay.) The Ali brothers and Kitchlew visited Poona and Gokak, where Kitchlew made… read more
With regard to action against ringleaders, the Ali brothers and Kitchlew have been arrest-ed. The drilling on the part of Moplahs was not extensive. He cannot see anything in the speeches of Willingdon and Lloyd to suggest a difference of opinion between… read more
Has endeavoured to keep Montagu informed of the effects of the Congress in his official telegrams. There were three outstanding features this year: (1) the feeling with regard to the amnesty and the Punjab; (2) the response to reforms; and (3) the Hindu-… read more
Has not seen Mohammad Ali's apology, but is not surprised that he should try to make one.
(Typed. Used for transmission.)
Will telegraph soon regarding a statement of policy at the opening of the Legislative Assembly. The Executive Council have decided to prosecute the Ali brothers and others involved in the passing of a resolution at the Karachi conference advising… read more
Treating certain offenders as ‘first-class misdemeanants’ would induce non-co-operationists to go to prison. However, he has privately instructed the prison authorities to moderate the Ali brothers’ physical hardships.
(Typed.)
Reports from the provinces indicate that Gandhi’s pronouncements since the arrest of the Ali brothers have had little effect. This failure will probably lead to more desperate courses at the meeting at Delhi on the restoration of the Congress Working… read more
The arrests of the Ali brothers have not led to disturbances.
(Typed.)
Refers to A3/9/2. Nothing is reported as having happened as the result of the meetings at which the formula of the Ali brothers has been repeated, and he has not yet received the opinion of the Bombay Government’s legal advisers, nor the Government of… read more
It is impossible to lay down a general rule for differentiating political prisoners from other offenders. Following Reading’s precedent in the case of the Ali brothers, Ronaldshay has instructed political prisoners to be given a more liberal diet, but if… read more
Sends in full the ‘agreed statement’ as given to the press: Lord Reading has been advised that his conversations with Gandhi about the Ali brothers have been inaccurately reported in the press, and he has therefore authorised the publication of an agreed… read more
Refers to A3/12/6. He is not suggesting that they should attempt to define political prisoners or allow it to be known that rigorous imprisonment would not be applied in any case, but is concerned that the world should think that they allow political… read more
Council have not yet decided whether to arrest Gandhi, as replies have not yet been received from the Bombay Government. Inquiries are also being made as to the effect of the Ali brothers’ speeches on the army. They are anxious not to be precipitate, but… read more